These have a good fit, but a narrow opening (really have to tug them on when it comes to the palm of the hand. I wouldn't size up though.
The vermillion color is more fluorescent red than orange (Giro "vermillion" seems to vary a bit between products - it can be bright orange to red, depending).
I'm on my second pair. The suede on the first pair ripped right along the edge of the pull tab the second time I used them. Competitive Cyclist was awesome about replacing them and I haven't had any issues with the new pair. They still feel a little fragile when pulling them on, but so far so good.
The padding is unobtrusive and the glove seems to breathe well. I'd rate much higher if the material didn't seem so weak.