The inner chamois is kick ass, I'm glad it's separate. The shorts are a little on the short side, but work fine. Hey when u ride with spandex wearers u fit in. If not, u might look out of place showing off a little upper leg.
I already had one and purchased a second. No problems yet. I like the fact that I don't have to take my tire off. My only issue is that you have to tighten it in the right position or the bike will lean. It's still secure but it kind of concerns me. Overall a good rack