Today was the first time I wore my Gore Tool Jacket. The weather was sunny, in the high 40's and windy. I was nice and toasty with no wind coming through the jacket. I actually worked up a light sweat.
I am 6'3" and weigh 215, 44 inch chest, and 34 inch waist. I went with the XXL because I wanted the ability to add an extra layer or two, the XXL jacket could be a little tighter at the waist, but otherwise the fit is good. Now that I have tried the jacket, I probably won't need to add an extra layer until the weather is in the low 40's. The sleeves stayed at my wrists and don't pull up while in the drops, the back of the jacket is long enough to overlap your pants.
The jacket is extremely well made.
It is a very nice looking jacket.